A die answered a question the table could not: what is true, and what do you learn? Council keeps the question and throws away the die. In its place stand two hands — one that takes, and one that gives. Learn these two and you have learned the game.
§ 2.1 THE TWO ANSWERS
When a scene raises a need the table cannot simply declare true, the world answers in one of two ways, and only two. An answer is either seized — bought with something of your own — or it is given, freely, by the hand that made this world. The first is price. The second is grace. Everything else in this book is these two, and the clues they both reach for.
Price
You pay, and you may demand. It costs the self and is always true.
Grace
You are given, and may not demand. It costs you nothing and cannot be earned.
§ 2.2 GRACE — THE GIVEN ANSWER
The keeper is the god of this small creation — not a tyrant, but a maker, who set its laws and largely lets them run. Grace is the maker's one free hand: the single thing in the game not bound by the world's own rules. An answer given as grace is unearned and unpriced — a truth set gently in a player's lap because they are stuck, and trying, and the story loves them.
Grace cannot be bought, banked, or demanded. A good-faith struggle invites it, and hope draws it near — but nothing compels it, for a grace that could be compelled would be only a wage. It may fall on the crew who tried hardest; it may fall, just as well, on the one who tried least and needed it most. It falls where it will.
Grace is not counted. There is no pool, no token, no tally at the table's edge. It is a posture of the keeper, not a currency of the players — and it has exactly one law that binds it: mercy. If a crew is truly aground, grace comes, because the maker will not let the story drown. Everything else about grace is free; only its mercy is a promise.
And grace comes quietly. It is a nudge slid across the table, unremarked — a detail noticed, a stranger who volunteers a word, a door found already ajar. The keeper need not announce it, and mostly should not. The crew will feel they were lucky. Let them.
Grace is not the keeper being kind against the rules. It is the one rule that kindness was allowed to keep.
§ 2.3 PRICE — THE SEIZED ANSWER
Where grace is given, price is taken — by you, from you. When you will not wait on grace, when you must know a thing now and are willing to bleed for it, you may seize the answer and pay in the only coin the game accepts: something of your own self. Price is the player's to demand, and the keeper may never refuse it — only name its cost.
The dearest altar of price is the Water — Landis, real only in water, who trades true answers for pieces of the one who asks. But mark this well: the Water is a rare road, not a daily one. A crew may sail whole seasons without seeking it, and should. It is the coin you spend when every cheaper road is shut and grace has not come. When you do go down to the water, the price climbs with each answer of a single visit:
FIRST
A truth. Confess a secret, or commit a new fact about yourself, aloud. It is canon the moment it is spoken.
SECOND
A trouble. The answer is true, and arrives lashed to a fresh complication of the keeper's making.
THIRD
The madness bleeds. You glimpse a thing the keeper knows and you should not. You must act on it, and cannot say why.
ALWAYS
A scene. To sit with Landis costs time; the weave moves on while you do. Paid on every visit, atop the rest.
§ 2.4 THE SEALS — WHAT BOTH HANDS REACH FOR
Price and grace do not invent their answers on the spot. They reach for the same thing: a clue the keeper wrote before play and sealed. Behind any obstacle worth being stuck on lie three clues, set face-down on the table, in order — so the crew can see that help exists and costs something, which is half the machine already turning.
THE FIRST
The Nudge
A single honest word or image. Enough to turn a head the right way, no more.
THE SECOND
The Bearing
What to do next — never why it works. A heading to steer by, not the chart.
THE THIRD
The Answer
The solution, plain as porridge. The last card, and the one no one should need.
They open in order, one at a time. Price opens the next by paying for it. Grace opens the next by giving it — most often the Nudge, slid over for nothing. Either way the clue is fixed; only the manner of its coming changes.
§ 2.5 THE ROADS TO A CLUE
A crew that means to pay has more than one road to the next seal — and the Water, being dearest, is the one they should walk least. In rough order of cheapness:
Honest search
Look in the world — dig, read, question, pry. Paid in effort and a scene's time. The first road to try, and the one grace loves best to reward.
A Work
Set the question as a labour and let the Tide carry it (Book the Third). Slow, but free of truth and trouble — priced only in watches.
A letter
Ask one who is absent but would know. Plain and free — but slow as the post, and read by whoever carries it.
The Water
Landis, and his climbing price (§2.3). Fast, dear, and always true — the road of last resort and first temptation. Walk it least.
The rule that binds every road: whichever you walk, it opens the next Seal in order — never a later one, never two at once. A road sets only how dearly and how fast you pay. And grace may still, at any hour, give freely what no road would sell.
§ 2.6 THE REWARD OF CLEVERNESS
Sometimes a crew closes out a whole labour — a Work, a mission, an obstacle worth being stuck on — with its Seals never broken: no price paid, no grace needed. Each Seal left closed is banked as Slack: a due at the Water. The next time the crew comes to Landis, that much of his usual price is simply waived — one price forgiven for every Seal they earned — and he throws in something past the ordinary menu besides, a thing he judges cool enough for the doing, never named in advance. Slack is spent only there, only with him, and does not linger forever unspent.
Solve it yourself, and the madman remembers you the next time you're wet.
COUNCIL · A PLAYER'S HANDBOOK · BOOK THE SECONDNEXT — BOOK THE THIRD: WORKS & THE TIDE